You know the foods great when it's locals eating dinner there. Service - we were well treated. My food was served in a timely manner and my tea never went empty. Ambiance - this is a small local restaurant. The dining room was a little crowded especially at the entrance, but being able to walk in the door and see the various desserts and salads on display adds to the charm of the restaurant. And makes me to want to try the desserts. They looked soo good. I had the pasta primavera. The sauce was not too thick and had a great taste. The vegetables tasted fresh and were plentiful. I haven't had something this good since little Italy in NYC. Definitely something I would try again!!!

Amazing! I wasn't sure what the pizza sizing was, a 12" is a enough for two people. The nice waitress informed me you can personalize each side. They do not skimp on toppings! We ordered the bruschetta as an app! Will always order again! I regret that I didn't ask about dessert and was taunted by all the delactable treats in the case as I walked out! Very cozy restaurant

Atmosphere is great! Service is great and the muffuletta was delicious!! My family and I visit regularly and have never had a bad experience! Would highly recommend

Best pizza in town! Have ordered the New Yorker several times and have never been disappointed!

The pizza is fantastic! The soups are so good, especially the shrimp bisque. The rosemary bread is a must.

Happy Mardi Gras season in the Panhandle!!! It's never too late to try your first muffuletta sandwich, and there is no better choice than New Yorker Deli and Pizzeria! The Muffuletta can be served hot & pressed upon request or as a cold sandwich. Made to order and piled high with delicatessen, a must try. Expect to leave with a full stomach! 01-07-2025

Wow, this is definitely a hidden gem here in Pensacola. The appearance will not draw you in the food will keep you coming back. The restaurant appears to be in an old house so it's not ideally laid out. Bottom line is there is decent seating and it appeared clean. The service was quick and very nice. We had lunch which was a BLT, Ham and Cheese Sub and a meatball sub which were all tremendous. We got desserts to go and they did not disappoint. We had baklava, carrot cake and chocolate mousse cake which were all very good. The carrot cake is probably the best I have ever had. We will definitely keep this on our list for when we return to the area.

Headed to Pensacola and wondering where to grab a pizza? Skip Domino's and order from here! If you have time and need a break from the beach, consider eating in ~ the vibe is friendly and relaxing, despite the busy hustle of the staff! In my three visits, I've concocted stories for the people seated around me ~ the two women who've been meeting for an end of week pizza and beer for thirty years, the two couples who've been meeting to chat over everything from kids to finances over pastas and salads forever, the guys in Naval Flight Training who are ending the day with pizza and debriefs ("Yeah! I thought I'd lost it when...") The food?! Just fabulous! Favorites are the Italian pizza and the pepperoni, but the Caesar Salad with chicken and the Greek Salad are also winners. A good selection of wines and beer. Parking is limited, but something always seems to open up. Indoor or outdoor seating. Give this place a try. If you have kids, order takeout. This food is GOOD!

The food here tastes like it came from mom's kitchen. Everything is made with care, and the waiters/waitresses are happy to recommend a favorite or answer questions about the menu. The whole restaurant feels like a NY bodega--very on theme. Parking here can be challenging, but if you're up for it, highly worth it.